Red Pin Geek
Search and AI visibility, built around your gemstone collections · for Mikel
All six collection pages live · first real read due 17 OctoberTimeline
Where you started, and where you are now
What is complete
What the numbers say, 16 October
The biggest thing sitting unused
What we are tracking
There are two different doors into your shop, and they no longer open together.
For years being findable meant one thing: showing up high in Google’s list of blue links. That still matters, and plenty of your customers shop exactly that way.
But a growing number never see that list. They ask an assistant a question in plain English and get back one answer, with a few makers named in it. Being named in that answer is a different thing from showing up high in Google’s list, and the two have come apart. Being strong in one does not carry you in the other.
So this section has two parts. The first asks: do assistants name you? The second asks: where do you sit in Google’s list? You are a striking example of the two disagreeing, and that disagreement is exactly where the opportunity is.
Four words used below, in plain terms. Being named is when an assistant mentions you anywhere in its answer. Being picked is stronger: the assistant puts you forward as the answer, not as one of a list. A listing is one time your page appeared in somebody’s Google results. Your spot is how far down that Google list you were, where 1st to 10th is the first page and almost nobody scrolls past it. A click from Google is somebody seeing your listing and choosing to open it.
1. Door one: do AI assistants name you? Six questions a real buyer would ask, put to four different AI tools on 27 August. Twenty-four answers in total.
| The buyer question | What happened |
|---|---|
| Independent makers of one-of-a-kind gemstone jewellery | Not named, 0 of 4 |
| Handmade jewellery from an independent Canadian designer near the Sunshine Coast | Picked by 3 of 4 |
| Designers who specialise in moonstone, turquoise or opal | Not named, 0 of 4 |
| Nature-inspired, west coast or artisan silversmith jewellery | Not named, 0 of 4 |
| Designers who work in ammolite or fossil | Not named, 0 of 4 |
| Ethical one-of-a-kind instead of mass-produced | Not named, 0 of 4 |
2. Door two: where do you sit in Google’s list? Your first six days of Google data, 26 to 31 August.
| First 6 days | |
|---|---|
| Times your pages appeared in Google results | 8,526 |
| Clicks from Google | 63 |
| Different search terms you appeared for | 1,105 |
| Different pages of yours that appeared | 358 |
The finding that explains both tables. Your home page says Sunshine Coast, in plain words, on the page. That is the one question the assistants get right about you. Fifteen of your seventeen gemstone collection pages have no words on them at all, so when somebody asks about moonstone or turquoise or opal, there is nothing on your site for a machine to read and repeat. The pattern is that exact, and it is the whole case for the work ahead.
You are not short of writing, and this is the encouraging part. All 304 of your products carry a description, and eight of your story collections carry your own writing, some of it 800 characters and genuinely lovely. The gap is not ability. It is that the writing never reached the gemstone pages, which are exactly the ones buyers search for.
Turquoise is the clearest opening you have. Google already puts your turquoise guide in the top ten, and around forty different turquoise questions bring up your pages between the 5th and 12th spot. Yet not one AI tool names you when somebody asks for a turquoise specialist. The reputation is already built. It simply is not reaching the assistants, and that is a much easier problem than starting from nothing.
Your biggest near-miss on Google. Your guide on the difference between solid gold, gold filled, gold vermeil and gold plated appeared 14,932 times in the last four weeks, sitting around the 6th spot, and was opened ten times. People are being shown it and choosing not to click, which almost always means the title and description in the results are not pulling their weight. That is a small fix with a large number behind it.
Your next moves
Check them off as you go; your progress saves on this device.